Home/Real events/Harvey: when a storm stops moving
North America / DOCUMENTED EVENT

Harvey: when a storm stops moving

A shrinking wind threat did not mean an ending rain threat. After Harvey made landfall in Texas, weak steering kept its circulation near the coast while rain repeatedly crossed the same region.

WHEN2017-08-23 — 2017-09-01
WHERETexas and Louisiana, United States
CONTEXTNorthern Hemisphere · 29.76°, -95.37°Approximate reference point for the named study region; not the center of the event or its full footprint.
Natural-color Terra MODIS satellite image of Hurricane Harvey over the western Gulf of Mexico, with a small eye, dense spiral cloud and the Texas coast to the northwest.
Event image

Documentary observation: Terra / MODIS, 25 August 2017, 17:25 UTC. This single cloud-top view predates Texas landfall. It does not show accumulated rain or flood depth.

NASA Earth Observatory / Joshua Stevens and Jesse Allen, using University of Wisconsin SSEC MODIS Direct Broadcast data. Source page also credits the NASA–NOAA GOES project for its separate animation. · Image source · Reuse terms
01 / THE RECORD

Follow the sequence

  1. A circulation reforms

    The National Hurricane Center reconstruction places a regenerated tropical depression in the Bay of Campeche at 12:00 UTC. This is a post-event analysis, not the first moment anyone saw cloud.

  2. The cloud system approaches

    Terra MODIS observed the hurricane at 17:25 UTC. The eye and curved cloud bands are visible; this image precedes landfall and is not a map of accumulated rainfall.

  3. Landfall, then a stall

    First Texas landfall occurred at 03:00 UTC, equivalent to 22:00 CDT on 25 August. Harvey weakened over land and its northwestward progress stopped later on 26 August.

  4. Another landfall

    Harvey came ashore near Cameron, Louisiana, at 08:00 UTC as a tropical storm. Rainfall impacts extended far beyond the small area of strongest winds.

Basis: Eric S. Blake and David A. Zelinsky, NOAA National Hurricane Center [1] · NOAA National Weather Service, Lake Charles [2] · NASA Earth Observatory [3]

Selected observations & analyses

These entries preserve the source’s reported quantities or analyses. They are not a newly processed observational dataset.

EvidenceReported value or findingProvenance
Texas landfall wind115 kt, maximum sustainedNHC best-track analysis; 03:00 UTC, 26 August 2017; a storm-intensity estimate, not a measurement everywhere.
Largest reported event rainfall60.58 in / 1,538.7 mm near NederlandNWS Lake Charles event summary; multi-day storm total, not an hourly rate.
Satellite observation25 August 2017, 17:25 UTCNASA Terra / MODIS natural-color image; visible cloud tops and land/ocean context.
02 / INTERPRET THE RECORD

The atmospheric mechanism

The NHC attributes rapid strengthening over the Gulf to a favorable environment including warm water, abundant mid-level moisture and weak vertical wind shear. But the mechanism that made rainfall last was different: the winds steering the whole cyclone became weak between larger high-pressure areas. A cyclone can contain fast rotating winds while its center hardly moves.

For interpretation, separate rain rate from residence time. Imagine two otherwise identical rainbands: one crosses a town once, while another repeatedly returns. The second can deliver a much larger total without a larger instantaneous rate. Harvey also interacted with a nearby frontal boundary. The conceptual cross-section on this site illustrates moisture convergence and rising air; its heights, arrows and timing are not recovered measurements of Harvey.

Basis: Eric S. Blake and David A. Zelinsky, NOAA National Hurricane Center [1] · NOAA National Weather Service, Lake Charles [2] · NASA Earth Observatory [3]

What the evidence does not establish

The satellite frame establishes cloud structure at one acquisition time. It cannot determine a gauge total, street-level flood depth, or the full temperature profile. The rainfall figure is a reported point maximum; neither it nor the hurricane category describes every location. This case explains meteorological ingredients, not the contribution of each factor to individual flood losses.

TAKE THIS INTO YOUR NEXT OBSERVATION

Compare the date of the cloud image, the landfall analysis and the rainfall accumulation window before connecting them. Different instruments answer different questions about the same event.

FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE

Sources & provenance

  1. Tropical Cyclone Report: Hurricane Harvey (AL092017) Eric S. Blake and David A. Zelinsky, NOAA National Hurricane Center · 2018-05-09, updated reportReference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.
  2. Hurricane Harvey 2017 NOAA National Weather Service, Lake Charles · Publication date not statedReference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.
  3. Hurricane Harvey Approaches Texas NASA Earth Observatory · 2017-08-26Reference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.

Explanations and diagrams are original educational interpretations. Source institutions have not endorsed or reviewed this publication. How we distinguish evidence from models.