Home/Real events/December 2021: thunderstorm winds and background winds overlapped
North America / DOCUMENTED EVENT

December 2021: thunderstorm winds and background winds overlapped

This unusual December episode combined warm air, a rapidly moving storm system, tornadoes, a derecho and damaging winds outside thunderstorms. Its central lesson is attribution: two damaging gusts during the same evening need not have been produced by the same physical mechanism.

WHEN2021-12-15 — 2021-12-16
WHEREIowa and the central United States, extending toward the Great Lakes
CONTEXTNorthern Hemisphere · 41.59°, -93.62°Approximate reference point for the named study region; not a tornado endpoint, a point maximum, or the full event footprint.
Aqua MODIS satellite view of the study region on 15 December 2021.
Context image

Aqua MODIS daylight view of the study region on 15 December 2021.

NASA EOSDIS GIBS/Worldview, Aqua MODIS · Image source · Reuse terms
01 / THE RECORD

Follow the sequence

  1. Warm air precedes a strong storm system

    NWS Des Moines describes a low-pressure system moving from the Colorado Rockies toward the Upper Midwest. Unseasonably warm air and strong environmental winds preceded the line of severe thunderstorms.

  2. A convective line produces tornadoes and damaging gusts

    The line crossed Iowa with numerous short tornado tracks and damaging thunderstorm winds. The survey later established a large statewide tornado count, which is different from the number of preliminary sightings or warnings.

  3. Strong winds continue beyond the convective line

    Overnight observations and the NWS Chicago report document strong non-thunderstorm winds into 16 December. In northern Illinois and northwestern Indiana, the damaging winds described by that office were not generated by thunderstorms.

Basis: NOAA National Weather Service, Des Moines [1] · NOAA National Weather Service, Chicago [2] · NOAA National Weather Service, Omaha/Valley [3]

Selected observations & analyses

These entries preserve the source’s reported quantities or analyses. They are not a newly processed observational dataset.

EvidenceReported value or findingProvenance
Assessed Iowa tornado count63 confirmed tornadoes, including 21 rated EF2NWS Des Moines updated event summary; a statewide post-survey count for 15 December, rather than the number of individual storm reports.
Non-thunderstorm airport gust74 mph / about 119 km/h at Des Moines International AirportNWS Des Moines event assessment identifies this as a non-thunderstorm gust after the line, not a tornado wind measurement.
A later local observation68 mph / about 109 km/h at Waukegan at 02:31 CST on 16 DecemberNWS Chicago compilation of high-wind observations; labelled as part of the non-thunderstorm wind episode.
02 / INTERPRET THE RECORD

The atmospheric mechanism

A pressure gradient associated with a strong cyclone accelerates the broader airflow. Separately, thunderstorms generate downdrafts, outflow boundaries and smaller circulations. When both processes occur in the same episode, their wind footprints and timing can overlap. Calling every gust a downburst would ignore the observations outside the convective line; calling every gust a background wind would ignore the concentrated storm-scale damage.

The winter date makes the event striking but does not supply its mechanism. Moisture, buoyancy, shear and the forcing of the strong system still need to be examined. An apparently modest buoyancy profile can coexist with strong winds and organized convection. The storms lab separates some of those ingredients, but its prescribed shear is not converted into a wind-gust or tornado prediction, and its buoyancy integral cannot partition observed damage between the competing processes.

Basis: NOAA National Weather Service, Des Moines [1] · NOAA National Weather Service, Chicago [2] · NOAA National Weather Service, Omaha/Valley [3]

What the evidence does not establish

The surveyed tornado count may be revised as evidence improves, and a regional maximum should not be applied to every community. Station exposure and instrument sampling differ. This case uses the agencies’ classification of thunderstorm versus non-thunderstorm winds rather than attempting to diagnose that distinction from the size of a reported gust alone.

TAKE THIS INTO YOUR NEXT OBSERVATION

Attach both a time and a mechanism to wind reports; similar gust speeds can arise inside a thunderstorm line or from the larger weather system.

FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE

Sources & provenance

  1. Severe Storms and Extreme Winds — December 15, 2021 NOAA National Weather Service, Des Moines · Publication date not statedReference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.
  2. December 15–16, 2021: Record Warmth Accompanied by Strong, Damaging Winds NOAA National Weather Service, Chicago · Publication date not statedReference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.
  3. Tornadoes, Derecho, Record Temperatures, Dust, Smoke, and Snow of December 15, 2021 NOAA National Weather Service, Omaha/Valley · Publication date not statedReference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.

Explanations and diagrams are original educational interpretations. Source institutions have not endorsed or reviewed this publication. How we distinguish evidence from models.