Home/Real events/Two satellites reveal the edges of California’s Tule fog
North America / DOCUMENTED EVENT

Two satellites reveal the edges of California’s Tule fog

Persistent valley fog on 5 January 2011 appeared in both geostationary and polar-orbiting satellite products. The comparison shows how repeated viewing, finer spatial detail and knowledge of terrain complement one another when identifying a low cloud layer.

WHEN2011-01-05
WHERECalifornia Central Valley, United States
CONTEXTNorthern Hemisphere · 37°, -120°Approximate reference point for the named study area; not an event boundary or a surveyed instrument position.
Aqua MODIS captured a low cloud layer following California’s Central Valley on 5 January 2011.
Event image

Aqua MODIS captured a low cloud layer following California’s Central Valley on 5 January 2011.

NASA EOSDIS GIBS/Worldview, Aqua MODIS · Image source · Reuse terms
01 / THE RECORD

What was observed

  1. Fog persists while its northern edge changes

    CIMSS documented fog across much of the Central Valley using GOES-11 visible imagery and MODIS products. The northern part began eroding during the afternoon while much of the remaining fog changed little, so one still image would miss a meaningful part of the story.

Basis: Scott Bachmeier / University of Wisconsin–Madison CIMSS [1] · NASA Earth Observatory [2]

Selected observations & analyses

These entries preserve the source’s reported quantities or analyses. They are not a newly processed observational dataset.

EvidenceReported value or findingProvenance
Observed afternoon evolutionErosion along the northern part of the fog, with persistence over much of the remainderCIMSS analysis of the 5 January GOES-11 visible-image sequence; an observed spatial change rather than a uniform clearing time.
Product spatial detailApproximately 1 km MODIS versus 4 km GOES-11 fog/stratus products in the comparisonCIMSS identifies sharper fog-edge detail in the finer-resolution MODIS product.
Retrieval limitationThe cloud-top-temperature product misidentified some cold snow-covered mountains as cloudCIMSS case analysis; a documented classification error over the Sierra Nevada, separate from the valley fog.
02 / INTERPRET THE RECORD

The atmospheric mechanism

Tule fog commonly develops when moist valley air cools toward saturation in a stable winter boundary layer. Surrounding terrain can help confine the cool air, while weak mixing limits exchange with drier air above. Once a thick layer forms, it can reduce sunlight reaching the surface and slow the heating that might otherwise help clear it. These are compatible formation and persistence processes, not a reconstructed temperature sounding for this particular day.

The instruments offer different strengths. A geostationary satellite can repeatedly watch the same region and reveal an edge retreating with time. A polar-orbiting pass can provide finer spatial detail but only at its overpass time. Combining the two helps separate a genuine changing boundary from the effect of pixel size. Neither improvement removes the need to understand what a retrieval measures.

Cold snow and cloud can produce confusing thermal signals. The reported misclassification is therefore a useful counterexample to treating a coloured satellite product as ground truth. A visible image, terrain knowledge and surface observations can help test the classification. Apparent brightness alone does not establish whether a white feature is snow on a mountain or droplets suspended over a valley.

Basis: Scott Bachmeier / University of Wisconsin–Madison CIMSS [1] · NASA Earth Observatory [2]

What the evidence does not establish

Satellite views show the top of a cloud or fog layer; they do not directly establish visibility at every road or whether cloud reaches the surface everywhere. The NASA background source illustrates a different Central Valley fog day, 17 January 2011, and is used only for formation context. No observations from that later scene are reassigned to 5 January.

TAKE THIS INTO YOUR NEXT OBSERVATION

Use image sequences for change, finer pixels for boundaries and independent observations for identification; no single satellite product answers all three questions.

FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE

Sources & provenance

  1. Tule fog in the Central Valley of California Scott Bachmeier / University of Wisconsin–Madison CIMSS · 2011-01-05Reference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.
  2. Winter Fog Becoming Rare in California NASA Earth Observatory · 2014-06-05Reference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.

Explanations and diagrams are original educational interpretations. Source institutions have not endorsed or reviewed this publication. How we distinguish evidence from models.