Home/Real events/A narrow band makes a very uneven snowstorm
North America / DOCUMENTED EVENT

A narrow band makes a very uneven snowstorm

Cold air crossing a relatively warm lake produced intense, persistent snowbands around Buffalo. Very different totals over short distances make this an especially clear case of why a regional snowfall forecast cannot be read as uniform coverage.

WHEN2022-11-17 — 2022-11-20
WHERELake Erie and western New York, United States
CONTEXTNorthern Hemisphere · 42.89°, -78.88°Approximate reference point for the named study region; not the center of the event or its full footprint.
False-colour satellite composite over the Great Lakes and northeastern United States.
Event image

17–20 November 2022 episode: a still from NOAA’s GOES-16 air-mass/lightning satellite composite. The colours are analytical, not natural colour, and this view does not measure snow depth. NOAA’s caption does not give this frame’s exact time.

NOAA / NESDIS, GOES-16 · Image source · Reuse terms
01 / THE RECORD

Follow the sequence

  1. Bands begin to organize

    NWS event records describe developing lake-effect bands around southern Erie County. Their placement depended strongly on the airflow across the lake.

  2. Heavy snow concentrates south of Buffalo

    Persistent bands delivered extreme local accumulation while nearby locations received much less. Band position mattered as much as the presence of cold air.

  3. The event total is assembled

    Reports from observers and stations were collected across the affected area. Later review examined whether proposed short-duration records met measurement standards.

Basis: NOAA National Weather Service, Buffalo [1] · NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information [2] · NOAA State Climate Extremes Committee [3]

Selected observations & analyses

These entries preserve the source’s reported quantities or analyses. They are not a newly processed observational dataset.

EvidenceReported value or findingProvenance
Buffalo Airport event snow36.6 in / 93.0 cmNCEI Storm Events Database event narrative; total for the multi-day episode.
Snowfall patternStrong local contrasts around the eastern lakesNWS Buffalo winter 2022–23 summary; regional event description.
Record reviewProposed new 24-hour state records were not acceptedState Climate Extremes Committee memorandum, 30 March 2023; measurement practices were reviewed.
02 / INTERPRET THE RECORD

The atmospheric mechanism

As cold air crosses open, warmer water, heat and moisture enter the lower atmosphere. The resulting instability supports clouds and snow downwind. A long path over water, sufficient moisture and a favorable wind profile help organize intense bands. Small changes in wind direction can shift a band across different neighborhoods, producing sharp gradients in event totals.

The observation lesson is as important as the cloud mechanism. Snowfall is measured using defined procedures; settling, drifting and the frequency of clearing a measuring board affect totals. The review of extraordinary reports did not deny that an extreme storm occurred. It asked whether particular measurements were suitable for a formal record comparison. That distinction is central to reading a number responsibly.

Basis: NOAA National Weather Service, Buffalo [1] · NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information [2] · NOAA State Climate Extremes Committee [3]

What the evidence does not establish

Snow depth on the ground, accumulated snowfall and liquid-water equivalent are different quantities. The airport’s event total should not be labelled a 24-hour amount or applied to the most heavily affected suburbs. The 2023 committee decision concerned proposed state records and observing procedures; it was not a claim that every local snow report was false.

TAKE THIS INTO YOUR NEXT OBSERVATION

For a narrow-band event, inspect location and time before magnitude. For an extraordinary record, inspect the measuring method as well: precision in the displayed number cannot substitute for a consistent procedure.

FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE

Sources & provenance

  1. Winter 2022–23 Summary NOAA National Weather Service, Buffalo · 2023Reference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.
  2. Storm Events Database: November 2022 lake-effect snow episode NOAA National Centers for Environmental Information · 2022 event recordReference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.
  3. State Climate Extremes Committee Decision Regarding 24-Hour State Snowfall Record for New York NOAA State Climate Extremes Committee · 2023-03-30Reference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.

Explanations and diagrams are original educational interpretations. Source institutions have not endorsed or reviewed this publication. How we distinguish evidence from models.