What to notice
Two aircraft cross the same blue sky: one leaves a short trail, while the other leaves a broadening white line.
What is happening?
Jet exhaust supplies water vapour and particles to air that can be extremely cold at cruising altitude. As the hot exhaust mixes with its surroundings, conditions can allow tiny liquid droplets to form on particles and then freeze. The visible line consists of ice crystals. Whether it forms depends on the mixed plume and surrounding conditions, so aircraft that seem close together from the ground need not leave similar trails.
Formation and persistence are separate questions. A new ice trail can disappear quickly if the surrounding air cannot sustain its crystals; the ice returns to vapour by sublimation. In air supersaturated with respect to ice, crystals can instead gain water from the surrounding atmosphere. A persistent trail may spread as winds and turbulence redistribute it. Ice saturation is a different reference from saturation over liquid water, an essential distinction in the cold upper troposphere.
Basis: Federal Aviation Administration [1] · Federal Aviation Administration / Environmental Protection Agency / NOAA [2] · NASA / Environmental Protection Agency / Federal Aviation Administration / NOAA [3]
Read the observation
- Follow one identifiable trail in a timed sequence. Record whether it disappears, remains narrow or broadens after the aircraft has passed.
- Note gaps along a trail and whether neighbouring trails behave similarly. Keep their unknown heights explicit when comparing them.
- Include the original line and surrounding cirrus in a wide photograph; an isolated crop of an old patch may erase the evidence of its origin.
A lasting trail does not require a visible natural cloud beforehand, and surface humidity does not describe the air at aircraft height.
Go a little deeper
A trail can begin or end abruptly where an aircraft crosses a boundary between regions with different temperature or humidity. That pattern does not require an abrupt change in aircraft operation. Nor does a dry afternoon at the ground establish that the flight-level air is dry. Upper-air humidity varies horizontally and vertically; the aircraft samples a narrow route through that three-dimensional structure. The duration of a trail is qualitative evidence, not a calibrated measurement of humidity.
Persistent contrails can eventually resemble other cirrus. Once the original line has dispersed, appearance alone may be insufficient to establish its history, which makes a sequence more informative than one photograph. The moisture lab provides the underlying idea that relative humidity depends on temperature, but uses saturation over liquid water at fixed pressure. It does not model aircraft exhaust mixing, ice supersaturation or contrail lifetime. Use its cooling experiment to understand the reference-temperature relationship, then retain the additional ice physics when interpreting a real trail.
Basis: Federal Aviation Administration [1] · Federal Aviation Administration / Environmental Protection Agency / NOAA [2] · NASA / Environmental Protection Agency / Federal Aviation Administration / NOAA [3]
Sources & provenance
- Contrails Federal Aviation Administration · Publication date not statedReference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.
- Contrails Fact Sheet Federal Aviation Administration / Environmental Protection Agency / NOAA · Publication date not statedReference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.
- Aircraft Contrails Factsheet NASA / Environmental Protection Agency / Federal Aviation Administration / NOAA · September 2000Reference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.
Explanations and diagrams are original educational interpretations. Source institutions have not endorsed or reviewed this publication. How we distinguish evidence from models.