Home/Field guides/A chance of what, where and when?
Forecasts & uncertainty / FIELD GUIDE

A chance of what, where and when?

A precipitation probability is meaningful only after its amount threshold, location and time window are defined. Products differ.

NowLaterThreshold
Illustration of a related weather process.

What to notice

A forecast shows a percentage beside rain, while another lists chances of exceeding several rainfall amounts.

What is happening?

For the US National Weather Service point forecast described in the cited guidance, probability of precipitation concerns at least 0.01 inch of precipitation at the forecast location during the specified period. That is approximately 0.254 mm. A 30% value does not state that rain lasts for 30% of the period, reaches 30% intensity, or covers exactly 30% of every reader’s surroundings.

Other products define different events. The Bureau of Meteorology’s referenced rainfall guidance describes chances of reaching specified amounts and commonly presents a range whose lower and upper values correspond to 75% and 25% exceedance probabilities. The displayed amount, location and accumulation period must be read together. A percentage without those details cannot be safely compared with another service’s percentage.

Basis: NOAA / National Weather Service Louisville [1] · Australian Bureau of Meteorology [2] · Australian Bureau of Meteorology [3] · ECMWF [4]

Read the observation

  • Name the amount threshold, place and period before interpreting the percentage.
  • Distinguish chance of measurable rain from chance of a larger total.
  • Check whether a range represents percentiles rather than hard minimum and maximum amounts.
A USEFUL DISTINCTION

Chance of rain is not universally the fraction of time or area that will be wet; read the particular product’s event definition.

Go a little deeper

Probabilities describe uncertainty, not a promise about a single outcome. A well-calibrated collection of forecasts assigning 30% to a defined event should see that event occur about 30% of the time across many comparable forecasts. One wet day does not prove that a 30% forecast was wrong, and one dry day does not prove that an 80% forecast was meaningless.

The lab uses a deliberately specified hypothetical event: a chosen rainfall threshold at one location over one modelled period. It counts the scenarios meeting that threshold. Increase the threshold and the exceedance fraction cannot increase for the same sample. This monotonic relationship is a useful check on a probability display. The demonstration is not a universal formula that multiplies confidence by area, nor is it a substitute for the definitions attached to an actual forecast.

Basis: NOAA / National Weather Service Louisville [1] · Australian Bureau of Meteorology [2] · Australian Bureau of Meteorology [3] · ECMWF [4]

FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE

Sources & provenance

  1. What Does Probability of Precipitation Mean? NOAA / National Weather Service Louisville · Publication date not statedReference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.
  2. Rain forecasting Australian Bureau of Meteorology · Publication date not statedReference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.
  3. Right as rain: How to interpret the daily rainfall forecast Australian Bureau of Meteorology · Publication date not statedReference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.
  4. Fact sheet: Ensemble weather forecasting ECMWF · Publication date not statedReference only; original paraphrase; no source media reproduced.

Explanations and diagrams are original educational interpretations. Source institutions have not endorsed or reviewed this publication. How we distinguish evidence from models.