Weather labs

Snow, rain or ice on the way down

HOW TO READ THIS EXPERIMENT

The physical idea

Surface temperature alone cannot describe the whole route taken by falling precipitation. Here every particle begins as snow at 3 km. It first crosses a fixed cold upper layer, then your selected middle layer, and finally your selected surface layer. A warm middle layer can melt the snow before it reaches subfreezing air near the ground. Whether melted drops refreeze before landing depends on more than the temperature at one point.

This is an explicitly illustrative classification, not a meteorological algorithm. Multiply each above-freezing layer’s temperature by its depth in kilometres to obtain a positive-temperature exposure. A value of at least 2 °C·km triggers complete melting in this experiment; smaller positive values remain labelled mixed. After complete melting, the lower cold layer triggers ice pellets only if its analogous cold exposure reaches 2 °C·km. Otherwise a subfreezing lower layer produces the freezing-rain pathway. These threshold values are editorial teaching choices.

Begin with a warm middle layer and a shallow cold surface layer. Deepen and cool the surface layer to switch from supercooled drops to the experiment’s refrozen pellets. Then remove the warm layer entirely to preserve snow. Inspect the data table while making these changes: it shows exactly which layers exist. Real particles have different sizes, fall speeds and thermal histories, and evaporation may cool the air toward its wet-bulb temperature.

Basis: NOAA / National Weather Service [1] · NOAA / National Weather Service [2]

What the model assumes

  • Snow begins at 3 km; upper layer fixed at −10 °C.
  • Middle and surface layers have constant selected temperatures.
  • Exposure proxy is temperature magnitude × depth in kilometres.
  • Complete melting and refreezing use selected 2 °C·km thresholds, explicitly not operational criteria.

Where the explanation stops

  • No particle microphysics, latent-heat budget, wet-bulb temperature or fall-time calculation.
  • The lab cannot determine actual precipitation type or icing severity.
  • The outcome called ice pellets is often called sleet in US terminology; usage differs internationally.
FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE

Sources & provenance

  1. Winter Precipitation Types NOAA / National Weather Service · Publication date not statedReference only; original explanations, calculations and diagrams. No source media reproduced.
  2. Freezing Rain and Sleet NOAA / National Weather Service · Publication date not statedReference only; original explanations, calculations and diagrams. No source media reproduced.

Explanations and diagrams are original educational interpretations. Source institutions have not endorsed or reviewed this publication. How we distinguish evidence from models.